About Us

On behalf of the people of Midstate Mutual Insurance Company, I welcome you to our public website.

Since its founding in 1879, Midstate Mutual has provided valuable insurance protection to its policyholders. Our home office is located in Auburn, New York, in an area commonly known as the Finger Lakes Region.

Please be sure to read the vision, mission and value statements of our company. You will also be able to read about our leadership, our affiliations and our financial strength. The mutual insurance industry is important to us. Our insurance products are sold exclusively through independent insurance agencies located throughout upstate New York. If you are not already a policyholder and are interested in one of our products, you may conveniently locate an independent agent who represents us by using our “Find an Agent” feature. We have an experienced, dedicated and well trained staff, ready to respond to the many challenges our policyholders may face.

2024 marks Midstate’s 145th year and we are proud to have helped and protected the people of upstate New York throughout those years. We are here to safeguard what is valuable to you. To our policyholders and agents representing us, please know we truly appreciate your trust and partnership.

Matthew A. Benedict
President and CEO